Indiegogo vs Kickstarter: Which Platform Should You Pick?


PUBLISHED


READ TIME

—

Indiegogo vs Kickstarter

Choosing between Indiegogo and Kickstarter is one of the first real decisions a crowdfunding founder makes, and it shapes everything that follows: your fees, your rules, who sees your campaign, and whether you keep the money if you miss your goal. The two platforms look similar from the outside, but they run on different funding models and suit different kinds of projects.

This guide breaks down Indiegogo vs Kickstarter on the things that actually decide your outcome: funding model, approval and rules, reach, fees, payments, success rate, and post-campaign options. By the end you will know which one fits your project, and when it makes sense to skip both and run your own platform instead.

Quick verdict

  • Pick Kickstarter if you want the biggest, most trusted audience for a creative, design, tech, or game project and you are comfortable with all-or-nothing funding (hit your goal or get nothing).
  • Pick Indiegogo if you want flexible funding (keep what you raise), you sell hardware or inventory-ready products, you operate outside Kickstarter’s supported countries, or you want to keep taking pre-orders after the campaign ends.
  • Fees are basically the same: both charge a 5 percent platform fee plus payment processing of roughly 3 to 5 percent, and neither charges a platform fee if your campaign does not collect funds.
  • The real difference is risk and flexibility: Kickstarter’s all-or-nothing model plus curated review builds backer trust; Indiegogo’s flexible funding and InDemand tool give creators more room and an ongoing sales channel.

Indiegogo vs Kickstarter at a glance

This Indiegogo vs Kickstarter comparison table sums up the differences before we dig into each one.

FactorKickstarterIndiegogo
Funding modelAll-or-nothing onlyFixed or flexible (keep what you raise)
ApprovalCurated review before launchMore open, faster to launch
Main focusCreative, design, film, games, techTech and hardware, plus a wide range
Audience reachLarger overall, US-heavyGlobal, strong outside the US
Platform fee5% of funds raised5% of funds raised
Payment processingAbout 3% to 5%About 3% plus $0.30 per transaction
Fee if goal missedNone (no funds collected)Flexible campaigns still pay fees on what they raise
Post-campaign salesLimitedInDemand (keep taking pre-orders)
Published success rateAbout 42%Not published
Best forFirst-time creative and product launches wanting reach and trustHardware, inventory-ready products, global creators, ongoing sales

Background: how the two platforms started

Both platforms launched in the late 2000s to help creators raise money directly from the people who believe in their work, and both have moved billions of dollars since.

Kickstarter launched in 2009, based in New York, with a tight focus on creative projects: art, design, film, music, publishing, games, and technology. It runs a curated model, campaigns are reviewed before they go live, and it has become the default name in crowdfunding for creative launches. Over its lifetime, Kickstarter has drawn well over $8 billion in pledges across hundreds of thousands of funded projects, according to Kickstarter’s own published stats.

Indiegogo launched in 2008, based in San Francisco, as one of the very first crowdfunding platforms. It took a more open, global approach from the start, accepting creators from more countries and a wider range of categories, and it built its reputation especially around hardware and tech products. Its signature feature is flexibility: creators can choose to keep the funds they raise even if they miss their goal.

Funding model: the biggest difference

In the Indiegogo vs Kickstarter decision, this is the point that matters most, because it changes what happens if your campaign falls short.

Kickstarter is all-or-nothing. You set a goal, and you only receive the money if you reach it by the deadline. Miss the goal and backers are never charged, so you get nothing. This sounds harsh, but it is also a trust signal: backers know they won’t pay for a project that is underfunded and likely to fail, which makes them more comfortable pledging.

Indiegogo vs Kickstarter

Indiegogo offers fixed or flexible funding. Fixed funding works like Kickstarter (hit the goal or collect nothing). Flexible funding lets you keep whatever you raise, even if you fall short. Flexibility is useful if any amount of money helps you move forward, but it shifts risk to backers, who may pay into a project that never reaches a workable budget.

The rule of thumb: all-or-nothing suits projects that genuinely need the full amount to deliver (most physical products), while flexible funding suits causes and projects where partial funding still does something useful.

Approval and rules

Kickstarter reviews every campaign before it launches and enforces stricter guidelines about what can be funded (it leans toward finished-enough creative and product projects, not raw ideas or charity). That review slows you down slightly but keeps overall quality, and backer trust, higher.

Indiegogo is more open and faster to launch, with a broader set of allowed categories. That lowers the barrier to starting, but it also means the platform carries a wider mix of campaign quality.

Reach and audience

Kickstarter has the larger overall audience and the stronger brand recognition, especially in the United States, which is where most of its traffic comes from. For a creative or product launch aiming at a US and global backer base, that reach is a real advantage.

Indiegogo has a genuinely global audience and tends to perform relatively better outside the US, including strong European participation. If your backers are international, or you are a creator in a country Kickstarter does not support, Indiegogo is often the more practical choice.

Fees: nearly identical

Fees are close enough that they rarely decide the matter.

  • Kickstarter: 5 percent platform fee on funds raised, plus payment processing of roughly 3 to 5 percent. Nothing is charged if your campaign does not fund.
  • Indiegogo: 5 percent platform fee, plus payment processing of about 3 percent plus $0.30 per transaction. On flexible-funding campaigns, you still pay fees on whatever you collect, even below goal.

So the platform cut is the same 5 percent on both. The meaningful fee nuance is that Kickstarter’s all-or-nothing model means you never pay a fee on a failed campaign, while an Indiegogo flexible campaign pays fees on partial funds.

Payments

Indiegogo supports a broad set of payment methods through Stripe, PayPal, bank transfer, and Apple and Google Pay, which helps with international backers.

Kickstarter processes pledges by debit and credit card (Visa, Mastercard, American Express, and others, with some card types limited to US-based projects). If you expect a lot of international backers using varied payment methods, Indiegogo’s options are more flexible.

Success rate

Kickstarter publishes its numbers, and its overall success rate sits around 42 percent, meaning a little under half of launched campaigns reach their goal. Indiegogo does not publish an official success rate, so direct comparison is not possible. What matters more than the platform average is your own preparation: campaigns that line up an audience before launch and build momentum early succeed far more often than the baseline, on either platform.

Post-campaign: InDemand

One Indiegogo advantage worth knowing: InDemand lets a funded campaign keep taking contributions and pre-orders after the official deadline, effectively turning a successful campaign into an ongoing sales channel while you move toward retail. Kickstarter has no direct equivalent, so campaigns there end more cleanly at the deadline. For a hardware or product creator who wants to keep selling to late backers, InDemand is a meaningful edge for Indiegogo.

Which should you choose?

The Indiegogo vs Kickstarter choice should come from your project, not the brand name:

  • Creative, design, film, music, publishing, or games: Kickstarter. It is where those backers already are, and the curated, all-or-nothing model fits projects that need the full budget to deliver.
  • Hardware and inventory-ready products: either works, but Indiegogo’s flexibility and InDemand give product founders more room, while Kickstarter offers more reach and trust. Many hardware teams test their audience first and pick based on where their backers cluster.
  • Global or non-US creators: Indiegogo, for its wider country support and international audience.
  • You want to keep every dollar even below goal: Indiegogo flexible funding.
  • You want maximum backer trust and the biggest brand: Kickstarter.

When to skip both and own your platform

Both platforms take 5 percent plus processing on everything you raise, and they own the backer relationship, not you. For a one-off campaign that is a fair trade for the audience and trust they provide. But if you plan to run campaigns repeatedly, or you want to keep the fees and the data, running your own crowdfunding platform becomes the better long-term move.

That is what Fundorex is for: a self-hosted crowdfunding and donation platform you buy once and own, with no per-campaign commission going to a third party, your own payment gateways, and full control of your data. If you want to understand that route, our guide on how to build your own crowdfunding platform covers it step by step.

Final thoughts

Indiegogo vs Kickstarter is less about which platform is better and more about which one fits your project. Kickstarter wins on reach, trust, and creative-project fit, with an all-or-nothing model that reassures backers. Indiegogo wins on flexibility, global reach, payment options, and the ability to keep selling after the campaign through InDemand.

Match the platform to your category, your funding needs, and where your backers are. And whichever you pick, remember that the platform is only the stage: a campaign succeeds on a clear story, a realistic goal, a strong video, and an audience lined up before launch day. For help on that side, see our guide on converting your crowdfunding landing page into leads and what makes a good crowdfunding campaign page.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main difference between Indiegogo and Kickstarter?

The biggest difference is the funding model. Kickstarter is all-or-nothing, so you only get the money if you reach your goal. Indiegogo offers flexible funding too, letting you keep whatever you raise even if you fall short. Kickstarter also curates campaigns before launch, while Indiegogo is more open and global.

Is Indiegogo or Kickstarter cheaper?

They cost about the same. Both charge a 5 percent platform fee plus payment processing of roughly 3 to 5 percent. Neither charges a platform fee if your campaign collects no funds, though Indiegogo flexible campaigns still pay fees on whatever they raise below goal.

Which platform has more backers?

Kickstarter has the larger overall audience and stronger brand recognition, especially in the United States, with over $8 billion pledged across its lifetime. Indiegogo has a strong global audience and often performs relatively better outside the US.

Can I keep the money if I don’t reach my goal?

On Kickstarter, no, it is all-or-nothing. On Indiegogo, yes, if you choose flexible funding, which lets you keep what you raise. If you pick Indiegogo fixed funding, it works like Kickstarter.

Which is better for hardware or product campaigns?

Both work well for products. Indiegogo is popular with hardware creators for its flexibility and InDemand tool, which keeps pre-orders open after the campaign. Kickstarter offers more reach and backer trust. Many product teams test where their audience is strongest, then choose accordingly.

Should I use Kickstarter, Indiegogo, or my own platform?

For a first or one-off campaign, use the platform where your backers already are. If you plan to fundraise repeatedly and want to avoid the per-campaign fee and own your data, a self-hosted platform like Fundorex is usually the better long-term choice.